Choose 2 kids for “choosers” and two convincers. The object of the game is to try and talk your way out of getting Pied in the face or talk your way into getting candy bar. Blindfold the 2 contestant, then give a pie to one convincer and a candy bar to the other.
The chooser has 30 seconds to choose one.
Each blindfolded contestant tries to talk the chooser into choosing them, but they don’t know if they are going to get pie or prize 🙂